[Nottingham] (no subject)

Roger Light roger at atchoo.org
Sat Nov 21 14:59:41 UTC 2015


On Sat, Nov 21, 2015 at 10:03 AM, david at gbenet.com <david at gbenet.com> wrote:

> People had have my old key will be aware they share the same information.

The point is that there's no guarantee it is in fact linked to you.
They met you, presumably checked your credentials, then signed your
key. This time, all there is is an email from someone alleging to use
the same email address (which isn't the same as in the key), signed by
the new key. Anybody could forge a mail with a fake gpg key saying the
same, without some link between the old key and the new there is no
reason to assume they are connected.

I've attached a different gpg key with the exact same parameters as
yours. By your reckoning, everyone should assume that it belongs to
you as well, which is clearly not the case.

If you don't care about the web of trust aspect, then sure ask people
to sign your keys without verification, but you should bear in mind it
then doesn't mean anything.

Cheers,

Roger
-------------- next part --------------
-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----
Version: GnuPG v1
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=aHiM
-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK-----


More information about the Nottingham mailing list