[YLUG] Free the BBC!

Arthur Clune arthur at clune.org
Mon Jun 11 09:58:36 BST 2007


On 10 Jun 2007, at 15:39, Noah Slater wrote:

>
> Actually, this is exactly how democracy works.

We're getting way off topic, and maybe I misunderstood what you wrote  
initially, but what you described at first read to me like a  
description of direct democracy, which we don't have, rather than  
representative democracy.

For an example of the difference, consider Labour's pledge to not  
introduce tuition fees in their election gumph and the way that they  
did just that after being elected. In our system there is no method  
for a direct vote on a single issue ("the BBC shouldn't use DRM") to  
affect the government. If that one issue is what matters to me above  
all, all I can do is hope that one party with a chance of being  
elected makes that a campaign pledge, and then sticks to it in office.

As I say, maybe I just misunderstood your inital post.

Arthur



More information about the York mailing list